In Search of Francis Saler and the Old St. Patrick’s

Historic American Buildings Survey, Creator, Francis Sadler, and Eugene L Pleitsch, Lavack, Theodore, photographer. St. Patrick’s Church, Sixth & Biddle Streets, Saint Louis, St. Louis Independent City, MO. Saint Louis Independent City Missouri St. Louis, 1933. Documentation Compiled After. Photograph. Library of Congress.

I’d been doing some research lately on the old St. Patrick’s Roman Catholic Church, which was completed around 1845 (the parish was founded in 1843 and closed in 1973), making it the third in St. Louis after the Old Cathedral and St. Mary of Victories, a German language parish. A familiar name came up, the Austrian-born Francis or Franz Saler, who is often listed as a builder or architect along with George I. Barnett, the latter of whom is considered the first classically trained architect in St. Louis. Barnett and Saler are listed as the architects of St. Mary of Victories and only Barnett for St. Vincent de Paul, but then only Saler is listed as the architect of St. Patrick’s.

Compton, Richard J, and Camille N Dry. Pictorial St. Louis, the great metropolis of the Mississippi valley; a topographical survey drawn in perspective A.D. St. Louis, Compton & co, 1876. Map. Library of Congress. Detail of Plate 22 showing St. Patrick’s Church (79) and School (80).

So what was Saler exactly? Was he an architect or a builder? My suspicions are that he was a builder/contractor in the same vein as the Medieval master mason; he was not classically trained in a classroom like Barnett, but he was rather practically trained by others on the job site in Austria and was capable of building a wide range of different types of buildings, ranging from houses, breweries and churches. In fact, he belonged to a St. Louis house building association, and he built the Washington Brewery for our dear friend George Schneider, who I argued in 2020 was not the founder of the Bavarian Brewery.

Sanborn Fire Insurance Maps, St. Louis, Missouri, 1909 February, Sheet 105; St. Patrick’s is located in the lower righthand corner of the map.

So if you look at the composition of St. Patrick’s, built only a year or two after St. Mary of Victories, which all primary sources seem to point to as a collaboration with Barnett, I can’t help but notice that the former is more or less a copy of the latter. There is a simple, wooden cupola on St. Patrick’s (which was later destroyed by a tornado), but for the most part, the church is one that could have easily come from the hands of a master builder relying on standard designs or pattern books, which were widely available. He very well might have just worked off of or even modified the blueprints of St. Mary of Victories.

Compton, Richard J, and Camille N Dry. Pictorial St. Louis, the great metropolis of the Mississippi valley; a topographical survey drawn in perspective A.D. St. Louis, Compton & co, 1876. Map.  Library of Congress. Plate 3, showing the neighborhood Saler lived in. 1226 S. 3rd is just to the left of Convent Street and St. Mary of Victories is no. 30.

When he died he lived at 1246 S. 3rd in what surely was a rapidly industrializing Chouteau’s Landing, around the corner from St. Mary of Victories, where his will paid $100 for masses given for his soul. With his death date, it would have placed his prime building years of the three churches in his mid-forties.

Due to some circumstantial evidence, I also think I’ve found his family burial plot in Calvary Cemetery; it would be logical that he would have been Catholic. They are almost completely illegible, but thanks to a burial plot map provided by cemetery staff, I could identify which headstone was which.

There’s far more to learn about Saler, but this is just some preliminary research I’ve done. I would definitely like to find a photograph if possible. Stay tuned.

3 Comments Add yours

  1. Cindy Rice says:

    Chris, thank you for your excellent history lessons!

    1. cnaffziger says:

      Thanks for reading, Cindy!

  2. Patrick J. Kleaver says:

    St. Patrick’s was a vital source of aid to the downtrodden during the Great Depression. The photo you posted shows men lined up for the soup kitchen run by Father Tim Dempsey, who was an advocate of the poor and pastor of the church from 1898 until he died in 1936. He was also a go-between in negotiating truces between the various gangs (such as Eagan’s Rats) who dominated the then densely populated neighborhood just north of downtown.

    The same year Father Dempsey died, the church was redone by volunteers with donated materials, and the front facade was changed to a “Spanish-mission” style,

    I attended St. Patrick’s elementary school for a short time in the mid-1960s. It was built in 1955 across the street from the church’s front, replacing the school built in 1872. It was thought a new school would attract families from newly-built Cochran Garden’s high-rise public housing project immediately to the church’s west. It initially did quite well, but by the time I went there the classes were small and it closed in 1972. Like the church, it was torn down a long time ago.

    By the way, Father Dempsey’s Charities continues on today by
    operating a soup kitchen and residence for men at 3427 Washington Avenue.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.